When Somebody Dies


Written by: Anne Hawkinson


The finality of death unlocks and flings open the floodgates of emotion, forcing us to accept the permanent loss, heartache, and emptiness it brings. Be it sudden or lingering, there’s no negotiating, no second chances. It’s over - too late (at least in this life) for all things unsaid, un-reconciled relationships, or un-mended bridges. In “The Hail Mary,” Dougal MacKenzie and Jack Randall experience an emotional spectrum like no other. But grief takes hold of people in ways as unique as they are as individuals. With alpha males like these two, what is it like for them when somebody dies?

Dougal taunts Colum and argues with him, even up until the very end. He’s angry that Colum has chosen Jamie as guardian to Hamish until he comes of age and tells him that he’s clearly using his decision as his “last chance to punish me for fathering Hamish.” If Dougal can assure Colum that he will care for his men as Jamie does, the guardianship will be his. Dougal storms out without answering (that’d be a ‘no’), but returns later and faces Colum alone. He won’t let it go, won't let Colum die in peace.

Photo courtesy: Variety

Without realizing that Colum is slipping away from an earthly existence (thank you, Claire), Dougal sits on the edge of the bed and laments the life the brothers could have had. It’s amazing insight into the softer, vulnerable side of Dougal. He believed his big brother was stronger and would always be there to protect him. “Nothing hurts you,” he says. Isn’t that the way we perceived our older siblings when we were young? Invincible? Indestructible? 

Dougal thinks that Colum’s physical appearance is the result of a fall from a horse at the age of ten. He blames him for falling off that stallion (too big for a ten-year-old to ride). “You betrayed me,” he says. The relationship they could have had ended - in Dougal’s eyes - when Colum fell from the horse, and Dougal hated him for it. “Instead of getting better, you got worse.” He blames Colum’s disintegrating health on a fall, both of them ignorant of the fact that it was a genetic disease that plagued Colum. I wonder if it would have made any difference to Dougal had he known. 

When Colum doesn’t respond to Dougal’s rantings, he reveals his anger, frustration (and heartbreak?). “No response. Damn your soul, answer me.”  When he realizes that Colum is gone, he finally breaks down and lays his head on Colum’s chest.

Photo courtesy: Porcelain Thunderbird

It’s the most tender, emotional Dougal I’ve ever seen. But he won’t accept any ownership in the broken relationship that is now beyond mending. He feels Colum has turned his back on him one last time, and blames him for the words that will remain unsaid and trapped in his head forever. It’s so much more complicated than Dougal will allow himself to admit, and at the end, he still blames Colum. “All because you couldn’t keep your ass on a bloody horse.”

Photo courtesy: Outlander TV News

The grief Dougal suppresses fuels his anger when he overhears Claire and Jamie discussing their one last chance to stop the battle at Culloden. He's pretty sure Claire played a role in Colum's death (he saw the small bottle of poison in Colum's hand) and is beyond angry at Jamie's apparent betrayal of him and all of the men who are fighting for the cause. There is no talking Dougal down, he attacks Jamie (who uses his body to protect Claire - as he vowed), and Claire ends up helping Jamie take Dougal's life. Jamie knows he had no choice, but he mourns his uncle and apologizes for what he had to do. Death fueling anger, and death fueling sorrow and regret.

Photo courtesy: Spoiler TV

Taking a closer look at another set of brothers, I was amazed at the tender, compassionate gestures Jack Randall displayed at the bedside of his brother, Alex. Cradling his head, holding his hand, and touching his cheek with what appeared to be genuine concern and love. He seemed fiercely protective of him, questioning Claire’s methods to ease his breathing, but ultimately relenting at her insistence, which must have been difficult.



Photo courtesy: MyM Buzz

He even went so far as to beg for her help with Alex – begging equates to weakness in Jack’s world, and he keeps any shred of human kindness at bay. Love and compassion have no place in the darkness Jack Randall inhabits.

Photo courtesy: FLAVORWIRE

There are times where there’s almost an emotional breakthrough with Jack. He comes so close that you’re sure he’s going to turn the corner and become a real human being. He sits on the bed, and Alex puts Mary’s and his hands together with his, encouraging the marriage and giving it his blessing. Jack seems accepting, swept along with his brother’s dying wish. Then something awakens in Jack, he snaps his hand away, and stands up and away from any emotional involvement.

When Claire seeks Jack out at the tavern, he begs her to talk Alex out of his request that he marry Mary Hawkins. He has enough awareness of his tortured, twisted self and has just enough decency (or whisky) to try and protect Mary and her unborn baby from him. But he can’t deny Alex his last request and reluctantly allows the marriage to take place. A sliver of decency finds its way out of the darkness, perhaps prodded along by the prediction of his own death in mere days (as provided by Claire).

Photo courtesy: fanpop 


The end finally comes for Alex - the room is silent except for the labored breathing that finally ceases. Mary weeps silently, Claire stands next to her, and Jack stares in disbelief at the lifeless body of his brother. He is heartbroken, and genuinely wants to cry. He almost does, but catches himself just in time. Alex knew there was a kind, gentle side to Jack, but we really don’t know what their young lives were like, or what, if anything, happened to Jack that led him into the darkness he now inhabits.

Jack’s reaction to Alex’s death is shocking, but tragically fitting. He silently straddles his dead brother and punches him repeatedly. Is he angry at the diseased lungs that took him? Jealous that Alex is free from pain and suffering? Grieving for the one person who knew, accepted, and loved him in spite of who he was? We’ll never know. Claire watches in horror as she shields Mary from his disturbing reaction. The room remains silent as Jack climbs off and straightens himself, smooths his hair, does that thing with his jaw, and walks out.

Photo courtesy: Blacklanderz



Two men, both uniquely and egotistically struck with having to get in the last word as a way to contend with the grief at losing their brother.  Their vulnerability shone only briefly in the throes of grief before their need to remain in control took over.  It might not be the textbook definition, but this is certainly on par with the many stages and forms of grief felt when somebody - especially one as close as a brother - dies.


What did you think of how the show portrayed grief in season two? 


3 comments

  1. Found the grief portrayed by BJR of course a bit weird,but it has showed his black soul and also his love for his brother!Death is final&tragic at any age especially family & loved ones.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Would love to challenge Diana Gabladon to write about JBR and Alex's upbringing. Would make a great novella!

    ReplyDelete
  3. If you would like an alternative to randomly approaching girls and trying to figure out the right thing to say...

    If you would rather have women hit on YOU, instead of spending your nights prowling around in filthy bars and nightclubs...

    Then I encourage you to watch this short video to uncover a shocking little secret that can literally get you your very own harem of beautiful women just 24 hours from now:

    FACEBOOK SEDUCTION SYSTEM!!!

    ReplyDelete

Back to Top